We earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
Comparison
Best Ice Makers 2026: 8 Home Models Compared
We compared the published specs of 8 home ice makers for 2026: nugget, clear-cube and bullet countertop models plus two 15-inch plumbed units, ranked by use.
B By the Best Ice Makers editorial team ·Published
At a glance
The GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra ranks first for soft nugget ice with a scale-inhibiting filter and app control. The Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255 is rated for more ice per day at a mid-range position, and the NewAir ClearIce40 makes clear cubes for drinks. Kitchens with plumbing can look at the NewAir 15" Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker.
A home ice maker solves one problem: ice that is ready when you want it, without trays. The eight machines here solve it in very different ways. Six are countertop units you fill by hand, making soft nugget ice, clear cubes or simple bullet ice. Two are 15-inch machines that connect to a water line and a drain and can sit under a counter.
We rank them by who each one suits, not by a single score. We do not handle the machines ourselves. The ranking comes from comparing the specifications that manufacturers publish in product pages and manuals, plus one published product evaluation, and we say so whenever a figure comes from a retailer listing or a third party. Each section links to a longer profile with the full spec list and a buying checklist. Commercial restaurant machines are a different category and are not covered here.
How We Chose
We weighed five things, in this order.
Ice type. Nugget ice is soft and chewable, clear cubes melt slowly and look good in a glass of spirits, and bullet ice is a plain, quick-chilling cube. Decide which ice you will actually use first.
Rated output and storage. The daily rating is a best case. The bin size tells you how much ice is ready at once, and it is small on every countertop machine here.
Water supply. A hand-filled reservoir needs no installation but needs fresh water, often daily. A water line and drain remove the chore and add plumbing.
Fit and noise. Footprint, clearance and the manufacturer’s noise rating matter more for a bedroom, a dorm or a small kitchen than for a basement bar.
Documentation and upkeep. We favored models where the maker publishes a manual and clear specs, and we note cleaning features, filters and warranty terms where we could confirm them.
Prices change often and Amazon does not allow us to quote them, so we do not. Each product box has a button that shows the current price on Amazon. As a rough guide to budget tiers, the NewAir ClearIce40, the Igloo and the Frigidaire EFIC128 sit at the entry-level end of this lineup, the Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255 and the NewAir NIM044BS00 in the middle, and the GE, the Whynter and the NewAir 15-inch undercounter at the premium end.
The 8 Models at a Glance
#
Model
Ice type
Rated daily output
Bin / storage
Water supply
Install type
Self-clean
1
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra
Nugget
Up to 38 lb (32 lb at 90°F ambient)
About 3 lb
Hand-filled reservoir
Countertop
Advanced Cleaning System
2
Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255
Nugget
Up to 44 lb
About 3 lb
Hand-filled reservoir
Countertop
Yes, cleaning cycle
3
NewAir ClearIce40
Clear cubes
Up to 40 lb
Not stated
Hand-filled reservoir
Countertop, freestanding
No
4
NewAir NIM044BS00
Nugget
44 lb (NewAir marketing)
3.3 lb
Hand-filled reservoir
Countertop
Yes, 15-minute cycle
5
Whynter UIM-502SS
Clear cubes
50 lb per manual (80 lb on product page)
Up to 25 lb
Water line and drain
Built-in or freestanding, 15 inches
Wash setting; manual cleaning
6
NewAir 15” Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker
Nugget
Up to 66 lb
17 lb (two buckets)
Direct water feed, pump drain
Built-in or freestanding, 15 inches
Cleaning function
7
Igloo ICEB26HNBK
Bullet
26 lb (Staples listing)
Basket up to 1.25 lb
Hand-filled 2-quart tank
Portable countertop
Yes, five cycles
8
Frigidaire EFIC128
Bullet
About 26 lb (12 kg)
Not stated
Hand-filled reservoir
Countertop
None listed
1. GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra — Nugget Ice with Filtration and App Control
The GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra is the version of GE’s countertop nugget machine built for people who care about water quality and convenience. According to GE, it accepts the Opal Scale Inhibiting Filter, which GE describes as reducing scale buildup and removing chlorine, volatile organic compounds and off flavors, and which lasts about 3 months. A separate washable air filter at the back keeps hair and debris out of the condenser. It also has built-in WiFi through SmartHQ and a magnetic stainless steel scoop that stores on the machine.
It is compact at 10.5 inches wide, 16.5 inches tall and 17.5 inches deep, and GE’s specification sheet lists a 44 dBA “Quiet Package” rating. The headline output is up to 38 lb per day at 70°F ambient and 32 lb per day under DOE rating conditions of 90°F, a reminder that a hot kitchen costs you ice. The bin holds only 3 lb, so it refills as you scoop rather than storing a reserve.
We rank it first because it has the most complete feature set and the clearest support documentation in the lineup. The catch is upkeep: GE recommends weekly cleaning and a descaling schedule based on water hardness, including an 18-hour vinegar soak. Read the full GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra profile.
2. Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255 — High Output at a Mid-Range Position
The EFIC255 is a countertop nugget machine with no plumbing, a pull-out ice drawer, a drain plug and a CLEAN button. The use and care manual lists up to 44 lb (20 kg) per 24 hours, and the ice bin is about 3 lb according to the spec sheet that a published evaluation cites. It runs on 115 V at 185 W and weighs about 35 lb, according to that evaluation.
That evaluation called the ice very clean and neutral but harder than GE’s Opal pellets, which also means it melts more slowly in a long drink. Its most consistent complaint was noise: the machine was described as noticeably loud, with irregular growling sounds. Frigidaire’s manual gives no decibel rating, so we cannot give a number. The one-year limited warranty is handled by Curtis International, which makes the appliance under license.
It ranks second because it offers a higher daily rating than the GE from a lower rung of the lineup. It loses ground on noise, ice texture and the absence of an app or filter system. See the Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255 profile.
An entry-level way to get clearer, slower-melting ice for drinks at home, best for buyers who value looks and dilution control over big cubes or automation.
What we like
Makes clear cubes by freezing water layer by layer, according to NewAir
Rated by NewAir for up to 40 lb of ice per day
Compact stainless steel body with simple two-button controls
Drawbacks
No self-cleaning function and no timer
Small cubes, not large cocktail cubes, and the sources disagree on cycle time and warranty length
The ClearIce40 is the pick for anyone who wants clearer ice without installing an undercounter machine. NewAir says water cascades over a super-cooled tray and freezes layer by layer, leaving no room for gas or impurities, and that the result melts more slowly and tastes cleaner. It is a freestanding stainless steel unit, 11.4 inches wide, 13.75 inches high and 14.5 inches deep, weighing 23.15 lb on NewAir’s page. NewAir rates it at up to 40 lb per day.
The sources disagree on speed. NewAir’s page says a new batch arrives every seven minutes, while the manual says a cycle takes about 15 to 30 minutes depending on room temperature, so plan around the manual. The manual also describes a thicker-cube option that adds about three minutes per cycle. The cubes are small, not the large blocks you see at a craft cocktail bar. There is no self-cleaning function and no timer, and NewAir’s page advertises a 2-year warranty while the manual describes 1 year.
We rank it third because it is the only countertop clear-ice option and an entry-level route to slow-melting cubes. Its trade-offs are manual cleaning and limited automation. See the NewAir ClearIce40 profile.
The NIM044BS00 is built around a narrow body: according to its owner’s manual it is 9.75 inches wide, 15.04 inches deep and 16.54 inches high, with a net weight of 34.17 lb. NewAir markets it at 44 lb per day, and the manual lists a 3.3 lb ice bucket. It has an ice drawer with an observation window, an interior light you can switch on, and a CLEAN button that runs a 15-minute cycle.
There is a documentation wrinkle. The NewAir product page we opened for this ASIN describes a related model, the NIM044BSN2, with different figures, so we rely on the NIM044BS00 manual and do not quote its noise rating or reservoir size from the other page. The manual calls for 6 inches of clearance at the back and sides and daily water changes, and it describes a one-year limited warranty.
It ranks fourth because it matches the Frigidaire’s rated output in a smaller footprint with a self-clean cycle, but offers fewer extras than the GE and has a short warranty. It is the nugget machine to look at when counter width is the constraint. See the NewAir NIM044BS00 profile.
5. Whynter UIM-502SS — Plumbed Clear Ice for a Home Bar
The Whynter UIM-502SS is a 15-inch machine that works built-in or freestanding, with a reversible door. According to Whynter, it makes clear cubes by recirculating water over the freezing surface, stores up to 25 lb of ice and ships with an NSF-certified inline water filter, a water hose, a drain hose and a scoop. Its body is 32.8 inches high, 14.6 inches wide and 23.6 inches deep.
Capacity is the figure to watch. Whynter’s product page says up to 80 lb per day, but the instruction manual lists 50 lb per day and says output varies with room and water conditions. We plan around the manual. The manual also says a licensed plumber should install the machine and asks for a continuous water supply of at least 15 psi, a drain and clearance of 4 inches at the rear. Whynter states a one-year limited warranty.
It ranks fifth because it is the only plumbed clear-ice machine here and the best match for a bar, but it is only for buyers who already have water and a drain nearby. It is a poor fit for renters and dorm rooms. See the Whynter UIM-502SS profile.
This is the volume pick. According to NewAir, it makes up to 66 lb of nugget ice per day, holds 17 lb in two removable 8.5 lb buckets, and gives a first batch in 10 to 15 minutes. It connects directly to a water source and drains by pump, which means no reservoir to refill and more freedom in where the drain sits. It measures 17.9 inches deep, 15 inches wide and 33.1 inches high, weighs 62.8 lb, draws 226 W and is ETL/cETL listed.
A programmable timer lets you schedule production, and a cleaning function rinses the system. The noise rating is under 65 dB, which is a ceiling and not a quiet figure, so we would not put it in a bedroom. NewAir’s page states a 2-year warranty and describes the machine as suited to home and commercial use, so read the written terms if you plan commercial use. We could not open its manual, so check it for hose lengths and pump height.
It ranks sixth only because it demands plumbing. For a household that has the connections, nothing else here offers as much chewable ice. See the NewAir 15-inch undercounter nugget profile.
7. Igloo ICEB26HNBK — A Simple Portable Bullet Maker
The Igloo ICEB26HNBK is a small black machine with a carry handle, a see-through lid and an LED control panel. According to a Staples listing, it makes 26 lb of ice in 24 hours as long as its 2-quart water tank is kept full, with 9 cylinder-shaped cubes per cycle in as little as 7 minutes. You can choose small or large cubes, and the listing describes an automatic self-cleaning mode with five cleaning cycles.
The limits are clear. The basket holds only up to 1.25 lb of ice, so the machine stops after a few cycles unless you empty it, and it is not a freezer, so ice melts if left. Bullet ice is cloudy and not as soft as nugget. We could not find an official Igloo page or open a readable manual, which is why dimensions, weight and warranty are unconfirmed here.
It ranks seventh because it trades capacity and documentation for portability and an entry-level position. If it is for a dorm, check campus rules first. See the Igloo ICEB26HNBK profile.
8. Frigidaire EFIC128 — The Compact Budget Machine
The EFIC128 is the smallest and simplest machine in the ranking. The use and care manual lists about 26 lb (12 kg) of ice per 24 hours and 9 pieces per cycle, with a cycle of about 6 to 13 minutes depending on ice size and room temperature. It measures 8.7 inches wide, 11.6 inches deep and 11.4 inches high, and draws 90 to 120 W on 115 V.
Two indicators supervise the work: ADD WATER stops the machine until you refill, and ICE FULL stops it when the basket is full. A front drain cap empties the tank, and the manual says to change the water every 24 hours. The manual does not say that the unit keeps ice frozen, so treat it as an ice-on-demand machine. It states a one-year limited warranty. We found no Frigidaire product page, so our source is a third-party copy of the manual.
It ranks last because it makes small batches of cloudy ice and has the fewest conveniences. For a desk, a bar cart or a small kitchen where size and budget matter more than volume, it covers the basics. See the Frigidaire EFIC128 profile.
Which One Should You Buy? Recommendations by Use and Budget
Every machine here suits a different buyer. The picks below follow the ranking order, and the budget labels describe each model’s position within this lineup, not a price.
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra: Premium Pick for Soft Ice and Filtered Water
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra
For people who want soft nugget ice, a scale-inhibiting filter and app control, and who accept a 3 lb bin and regular descaling.
Three checks help you avoid a bad fit. First, measure: countertop machines need about 4 to 6 inches of clearance for ventilation, and the two 15-inch models need the cabinet opening, a water line and a drain. Second, plan for water: every hand-filled machine here needs its water changed regularly, and hard water means more descaling. Third, remember the bin: none of the countertop machines stores a reserve, so move ice to a freezer bag if you need more than a few pounds at once. If you are buying for a dorm, check your school’s housing rules on small appliances first.
The Bottom Line
Here is the ranking again in one place.
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Ultra: the most complete nugget machine, with filtration and WiFi.
Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255: a higher rated output at a mid-range position, with noise as the trade-off.
NewAir ClearIce40: the countertop route to clear cubes for drinks.
NewAir NIM044BS00: nugget ice in a body under 10 inches wide.
Whynter UIM-502SS: plumbed clear ice for a bar, sized by the manual’s 50 lb figure.
NewAir 15” Undercounter Nugget Ice Maker: the highest volume, if you have plumbing.
Igloo ICEB26HNBK: a simple portable bullet maker for small needs.
Frigidaire EFIC128: the most compact, basic option.
If you are unsure, start with the ice you like. For soft and chewable, look at the GE, the Frigidaire Gallery or the NewAir nugget models. For clear cubes in spirits, choose the ClearIce40 or the Whynter. For a quick, simple cube in a dorm, choose the Igloo or the Frigidaire EFIC128.
What is the difference between nugget ice, clear ice and bullet ice?
Nugget ice is made of small compressed pieces that are soft enough to chew and soak up the flavor of a drink. Clear cubes freeze layer by layer, which leaves out trapped air and impurities and melts more slowly. Bullet ice is small, cylindrical and usually cloudy, and it chills a drink quickly. In this ranking, the GE Opal, the Frigidaire Gallery EFIC255, the NewAir NIM044BS00 and the NewAir 15-inch undercounter make nugget ice; the NewAir ClearIce40 and the Whynter make clear cubes; and the Igloo and the Frigidaire EFIC128 make bullet ice.
Do I need a water line for an ice maker?
Only for two models here. The Whynter UIM-502SS and the NewAir 15-inch undercounter nugget machine connect to a water supply and a drain. The other six are countertop machines that you fill by hand, so they only need a grounded outlet.
How much ice does a home ice maker really make?
The daily figures on the box are maximums. They assume the machine runs nonstop, the reservoir stays full and the bin never fills. Heat lowers output: GE's own sheet lists 38 lb per day at 70°F ambient but 32 lb per day at 90°F, and the Whynter manual lists 50 lb per day against 80 lb on the product page. Size your purchase using the lower number.
Do countertop ice makers keep ice frozen?
No. The bins on these machines are drawers or baskets, not freezers, so ice melts over time. If you want ice for tomorrow, move it to a freezer bag or container.
Which of these makes ice for cocktails and whiskey?
The NewAir ClearIce40 on a counter and the Whynter UIM-502SS built in under one both make clear cubes, which melt more slowly than cloudy ice. Neither makes the large single cubes or spheres some bars use, so for those you still need a silicone mold.
How often should I clean an ice maker?
Follow the manual, since the schedules differ. Several manuals here say to change the reservoir water every 24 hours, and GE recommends weekly cleaning plus descaling that depends on water hardness. A self-cleaning cycle helps but does not replace routine wiping and descaling.