Independent guide · November 2026

The right
ice maker for your kitchen or bar,
without the guesswork.

We compared 8 ice makers on the same criteria: ice type, daily output, bin size, water supply and cleaning.

8 models compared Same criteria for every model 100% independent
The ranking

The three that stand out in 2026

The full ranking

Our product profiles

All product profiles (8)

What to know before you buy

All guides (3)

A site funded by its readers, not by brands

I.

Fully independent

No manufacturer pays us. Our only income is Amazon commissions, which are the same whichever product you choose.

II.

A consistent method

Every model is assessed on the same criteria: Ice type (nugget, clear cube, bullet), rated daily output in pounds per 24 hours and first-batch time, storage bin size and whether the bin is refrigerated, water supply (refillable reservoir or direct water line) and drain needs, countertop footprint or 15-inch undercounter fit, self-cleaning and descaling, ETL or UL listing, noise, warranty length, value within its range.

III.

Kept up to date

Availability and new models: we revisit our rankings regularly.